Musigny Grand Cru Vieilles Vignes Magnum - 2013 - Domaine Comte de Vogue
Allergic-Info: This wine can contain sulfites
Alcoholic content: 11.50 %
yr. 2001 Jeannie Cho Lee:
96 of 100 Points.
"Jeannie Cho Lee" has rated the wine "Domaine Comte Georges de Vogue Musigny Grand Cru 'Cuvee Vieilles Vignes', Cote de Nuits, France" from the vintage 2001 on 01.12.2016 with 96 of 100 points.
"This is a sensual, youthful Musigny by the largest and one of the top producers of Musigny (Vogue owns 7 out of 10.8 hectares). There is much youthful exuberance and primary fruit with silky, sensual tannins. The finish is long and lingering. This is a vintage I would lay down until at least 2020."
yr. 2001 Doctorwine:
96 of 100 Points.
"Doctorwine" has rated the wine "Domaine Comte Georges de Vogue Musigny Grand Cru 'Cuvee Vieilles Vignes', Cote de Nuits, France" from the vintage 2001 on 05.07.2016 with 96 of 100 points.
"A classic, clear red color with pronounced orange notes. The bouquet opens like a peacock's tail with austere notes of currant jam, tobacco, antique leather and garigue. It is incredible how it changes in the glass with breathing. The mouthfeel is austere, rich and creates a great sensorial effect."
yr. 1978 Jeannie Cho Lee:
100 of 100 Points.
"Jeannie Cho Lee" has rated the wine "Domaine Comte Georges de Vogue Musigny Grand Cru 'Cuvee Vieilles Vignes', Cote de Nuits, France" from the vintage 1978 on 01.06.2016 with 100 of 100 points.
"This phenomenal wine is so beautiful and so perfect that it is surreal. The nose is a complex arrray of both dried and fresh flowers that is as intoxicating as a great woman's perfume. The palate is silky and persistent, offering layers of seductive red fruit and floral flavors combined with exotic spices. The tannins are so silky they are barely there and the finish is incredibly long and lingering. This is a perfect Vogue Musigny."
yr. 2014 Jeannie Cho Lee:
96 of 100 Points.
"Jeannie Cho Lee" has rated the wine "Domaine Comte Georges de Vogue Musigny Grand Cru 'Cuvee Vieilles Vignes', Cote de Nuits, France" from the vintage 2014 on 01.12.2015 with 96 of 100 points.
"A mix of lovely red flowers - peony, purple lilac and violets on the nose - the palate is sweet, filled with a mix of red and black berries and sweet spices. Incredibly approachable and linear with lovely purity and long length. There was about 20% damage from hail in this vintage for Musigny. A delicious vintage with fine intensity and harmony to see it through for decades of aging."
yr. 2000 Jeannie Cho Lee:
95 of 100 Points.
"Jeannie Cho Lee" has rated the wine "Domaine Comte Georges de Vogue Musigny Grand Cru 'Cuvee Vieilles Vignes', Cote de Nuits, France" from the vintage 2000 on 01.11.2015 with 95 of 100 points.
"This is a gorgeous Musigny, just starting to open up and show bottle aged characters of mushrooms and leather. The palate is complex and layered with a firm grippy finish, suggesting a long life ahead. Enjoy now and for the next decade or more."
yr. 1995 Jeannie Cho Lee:
92 of 100 Points.
"Jeannie Cho Lee" has rated the wine "Domaine Comte Georges de Vogue Musigny Grand Cru 'Cuvee Vieilles Vignes', Cote de Nuits, France" from the vintage 1995 on 01.11.2015 with 92 of 100 points.
"This vintage of Musigny tastes a bit disjointed although the flavors are all there - the floral and herbal notes stands apart from the firm tannins and acidity. Chunky on the palate, missing the ethereal lightness typical of Vogue's Musigy in most vintages."
yr. 2013 Jeannie Cho Lee:
95 of 100 Points.
"Jeannie Cho Lee" has rated the wine "Domaine Comte Georges de Vogue Musigny Grand Cru 'Cuvee Vieilles Vignes', Cote de Nuits, France" from the vintage 2013 on 25.11.2014 with 95 of 100 points.
"Fairly reserved on the nose with hints of red flowers and bright red fruits. Palate is more expressive with raspberry, cherry and sweet spices. Wonderful purity in this vintage with minerality and lovely flowers. Delicate, gentle power behind the minerally flavors. Give it at least 6 years before approaching. Tasted in: Burgundy, France. Maturity: Young."
yr. 2012 Jeannie Cho Lee:
98 of 100 Points.
"Jeannie Cho Lee" has rated the wine "Domaine Comte Georges de Vogue Musigny Grand Cru 'Cuvee Vieilles Vignes', Cote de Nuits, France" from the vintage 2012 on 05.11.2013 with 98 of 100 points.
"A magical, transcendental Musigny capturing both the light, joyfulness and depth of this vintage. Profound, expressive, complex and very long. A magnificent Musigny. Tasted in: Burgundy, France. Maturity: Young."
yr. 2011 Jeannie Cho Lee:
94 of 100 Points.
"Jeannie Cho Lee" has rated the wine "Domaine Comte Georges de Vogue Musigny Grand Cru 'Cuvee Vieilles Vignes', Cote de Nuits, France" from the vintage 2011 on 16.11.2012 with 94 of 100 points.
"Vogues Musigny is always ethereal - delicate yet persistent. An array of flavours that are lingering - roses, violets, herbs, spices, earth. Trademark silky texture with a delicate palate and very long finish. As Millet says, This wine has purity and minerality. You can see the bottom of the lake." Crystalline pure and sensual. Gorgeous wine. Drink: 2017-2027" Tasted in: Burgundy, France. Maturity: Young."
yr. 2010 Jeannie Cho Lee:
96 of 100 Points.
"Jeannie Cho Lee" has rated the wine "Domaine Comte Georges de Vogue Musigny Grand Cru 'Cuvee Vieilles Vignes', Cote de Nuits, France" from the vintage 2010 on 15.11.2011 with 96 of 100 points.
"This Musigny sang from the barrel. The nose was delicate with an array of floral notes, spices, pomegranate and lively minerality. The flavours are pure and precise with delicacy as well as persistence. The palate has layers of flavours that combine intensity with freshness and finesse. This is a complex wine with a very long finish and the potential to age for decades. Tasted in: Bordeaux, France. Maturity: Drink."
yr. 2017 Adrian van Velsen - vvWine.ch:
97 of 100 Points.
"Adrian van Velsen - vvWine.ch" has rated the wine "Domaine Comte Georges de Vogue Musigny Grand Cru 'Cuvee Vieilles Vignes'" from the vintage 2017 on 01.11.2019 with 97 of 100 points.
"Helles Rubin. Herrliche Nase, kühl und rotfruchtig, viel Sauerkirsche, ungemein tiefgründig, rauchig, mit Luft auch viele Veilchen, man wähnt sich schon fast im Barolo was die Floralität angeht. Im Gaumen straff und top präzis, fantastische Frucht, wirkt bereits zugänglich, zeigt Knackigkeit, Struktur, Dichte und eine erhabene Eleganz, der Wein schwebt förmlich auf der Zunge, wirkt zu 100% balanciert, druckvoll aber ohne Schwere zieht er sich in einen beeindruckend langen Abgang. Ein Meisterwerk der Natur und des Winzers. 19.5 vvPunkte (97/100)."
yr. 1995 Tom Cannavan:
95 of 100 Points.
"Tom Cannavan" has rated the wine "Domaine Comte Georges de Vogue Musigny Grand Cru 'Cuvee Vieilles Vignes'" from the vintage 1995 on 01.01.2015 with 95 of 100 points.
"(2015) A super-expensive wine and a real treat to drink this single bottle from my cellar. The nose has some mustiness initially, but then begins to blossom, with briar and truffle, a sweet damp earth note and something firm and vegetal too, like liquorice root perhaps, a touch of beetroot. On the palate cool and structured: even at 20 years old this is not a softened and mellow, fading style. Instead it has taut black fruit at the core, some clove and bitter edge of endive, but the cherry-tight fruit persists. Lovely acidity here, tingling on the lips with the tight tannins and that spine of pure, serious concentation. Magical. Drunk from Zalto Burgundy glasses."
yr. 1972 Tom Cannavan:
94 of 100 Points.
"Tom Cannavan" has rated the wine "Domaine Comte Georges de Vogue Musigny Grand Cru 'Cuvee Vieilles Vignes'" from the vintage 1972 on 01.01.2009 with 94 of 100 points.
"(2009) Lots of leafy character here, with a touch of stewed prune and a haunting echo of plump red fruit and a little bit of earthiness. On the palate this is a little short, although the palate maintains a sweet core. Nice supple tannins, and a sweetness persists. Maybe not so short, and a wine that works its way into your heart."
yr. 1994 Tom Cannavan:
94 of 100 Points.
"Tom Cannavan" has rated the wine "Domaine Comte Georges de Vogue Musigny Grand Cru 'Cuvee Vieilles Vignes'" from the vintage 1994 on 01.01.2009 with 94 of 100 points.
"(2009) >From magnum. Fantastically rich, seductive nose. The colour is much more evolved than the Beaune, but whilst this is open and charming, there's a firmness and a firm cherry backbone. Lovely old polished wood, touches of spice and ground coffee. Lovely structure and power in this."
yr. 2003 Falstaff:
91 of 100 Points.
"Falstaff" has rated the wine "Domaine Comte Georges de Vogue Musigny Grand Cru 'Cuvee Vieilles Vignes'" from the vintage 2003 on 01.05.2006 with 91 of 100 points.
"Kräftiges Rubingranat, zarter Wasserrand, Randaufhellung. In der Nase sehr individuelle Noten nach Eukalyptus und Tabak, stark blättrig, aber auch Noten von gekochten Früchten, Dörrobst. Am Gaumen rund und üppig, zart pfeffrige Note, gute Balance, hat kraftvolle Tannine, bereits balanciert, bleibt haften, hat viel Kraft, braucht noch einige Jahre auf der Flasche, um an Eleganz zuzulegen. Die Mehrheit der Verkoster der Grand Jury lehnte diesen Wein deutlich ab, was ihm in der Gesamtwertung einen Absturz bescherte."
yr. 1990 Falstaff:
90 of 100 Points.
"Falstaff" has rated the wine "Domaine Comte Georges de Vogue Musigny Grand Cru 'Cuvee Vieilles Vignes'" from the vintage 1990 on 01.05.2006 with 90 of 100 points.
"Mittleres Karmingranat, breiterer Wasserrand, Randaufhellung. In der Nase deutlicher Alterston, zart madeirisiert, alte Schokolade, etwas Politur, intensive Tabaknote, mit Luft immer mehr Nougat und Orangenschale. Am Gaumen süß und komplex, feine nussige Aromen, angenehmer Schokotouch, etwas Dörrobst, frische Textur, zitronige Nuancen, ein recht stoffiger Wein, mit guter Süße ausgestattet, der aber doch schon ein klein wenig unfrisch wirkt. Um diesen Wein zur Geltung zu bringen, muss man ihn einen Tag vorher dekantieren, weil er extrem verschlossen ist. Ob dieser Wein sein Terroir darstellt, bleibt weiterhin eine Frage, über die sich trefflich streiten lässt."
yr. 1991 Tom Cannavan:
93 of 100 Points.
"Tom Cannavan" has rated the wine "Domaine Comte Georges de Vogue Musigny Grand Cru 'Cuvee Vieilles Vignes'" from the vintage 1991 on 01.01.2003 with 93 of 100 points.
"(2003) The deep cherry red colour is very youthful, though just a hint of brown at rim. Essence of truffle, woodsmoke and damp woodland floor, with a ripe cherry and blackberry fruit character. Plenty of sweet vanilla in the background. Fine, earthy, gorgeously animal palate with bloody notes suffused with dried cherry and tobacco. Great acidity, powerful tannins and rather young, though fabulous length."
yr. 2000 Wine Enthusiast:
98 of 100 Points.
"Wine Enthusiast" has rated the wine "Domaine Comte Georges de Vogue Musigny Grand Cru 'Cuvee Vieilles Vignes'" from the vintage 2000 on 01.01.2002 with 98 of 100 points.
"This is great red Burgundy from the oldest domaine in the village. It is all there: powerful floral aromas, flavors of a coulis of black fruits, ripe tannins and sweet fruit with balancing acidity. The wine manages to combine a deep, almost brooding strength with a dense, silky texture. For a 2000, a lesser year than 1999, this is a great achievement. Keep for at least 12 years."
yr. 2018 Jasper Morris - Inside Burgundy:
92 of 100 Points.
"Jasper Morris - Inside Burgundy" has rated the wine "Domaine Comte Georges de Vogue Musigny Grand Cru 'Cuvee Vieilles Vignes'" from the vintage 2018 on 01.09.2022 with 92 of 100 points.
yr. 2012 Jasper Morris - Inside Burgundy:
94 of 100 Points.
"Jasper Morris - Inside Burgundy" has rated the wine "Domaine Comte Georges de Vogue Musigny Grand Cru 'Cuvee Vieilles Vignes'" from the vintage 2012 on 01.06.2022 with 94 of 100 points.
yr. 2020 Jasper Morris - Inside Burgundy:
94 - 98 of 100 Points.
"Jasper Morris - Inside Burgundy" has rated the wine "Domaine Comte Georges de Vogue Musigny Grand Cru 'Cuvee Vieilles Vignes'" from the vintage 2020 on 01.11.2021 with 94 - 98 of 100 points.
yr. 2020 Tim Atkin:
97 of 100 Points.
"Tim Atkin" has rated the wine "Domaine Comte Georges de Vogue Musigny Grand Cru 'Cuvee Vieilles Vignes'" from the vintage 2020 on 01.11.2021 with 97 of 100 points.
yr. 2017 Jasper Morris - Inside Burgundy:
91 of 100 Points.
"Jasper Morris - Inside Burgundy" has rated the wine "Domaine Comte Georges de Vogue Musigny Grand Cru 'Cuvee Vieilles Vignes'" from the vintage 2017 on 01.09.2021 with 91 of 100 points.
yr. 2018 La Revue du Vin de France:
19 of 20 Points.
"La Revue du Vin de France" has rated the wine "Domaine Comte Georges de Vogue Musigny Grand Cru 'Cuvee Vieilles Vignes'" from the vintage 2018 on 01.01.2021 with 19 of 20 points.
yr. 2019 Jasper Morris - Inside Burgundy:
96 - 100 of 100 Points.
"Jasper Morris - Inside Burgundy" has rated the wine "Domaine Comte Georges de Vogue Musigny Grand Cru 'Cuvee Vieilles Vignes'" from the vintage 2019 on 01.11.2020 with 96 - 100 of 100 points.
yr. 1947 Robert Parker The Wine Advocate:
100 of 100 Points.
"Robert Parker The Wine Advocate" has rated the wine "Domaine Comte Georges de Vogue Musigny Grand Cru 'Cuvee Vieilles Vignes'" from the vintage 1947 on 01.07.2020 with 100 of 100 points.
yr. 1945 Robert Parker The Wine Advocate:
95 of 100 Points.
"Robert Parker The Wine Advocate" has rated the wine "Domaine Comte Georges de Vogue Musigny Grand Cru 'Cuvee Vieilles Vignes'" from the vintage 1945 on 01.07.2020 with 95 of 100 points.
yr. 2017 La Revue du Vin de France:
18 of 20 Points.
"La Revue du Vin de France" has rated the wine "Domaine Comte Georges de Vogue Musigny Grand Cru 'Cuvee Vieilles Vignes'" from the vintage 2017 on 01.01.2020 with 18 of 20 points.
yr. 2018 Tim Atkin:
95 of 100 Points.
"Tim Atkin" has rated the wine "Domaine Comte Georges de Vogue Musigny Grand Cru 'Cuvee Vieilles Vignes'" from the vintage 2018 on 01.11.2019 with 95 of 100 points.
yr. 2016 Jasper Morris - Inside Burgundy:
96 of 100 Points.
"Jasper Morris - Inside Burgundy" has rated the wine "Domaine Comte Georges de Vogue Musigny Grand Cru 'Cuvee Vieilles Vignes'" from the vintage 2016 on 01.09.2019 with 96 of 100 points.
yr. 2009 Jasper Morris - Inside Burgundy:
95 of 100 Points.
"Jasper Morris - Inside Burgundy" has rated the wine "Domaine Comte Georges de Vogue Musigny Grand Cru 'Cuvee Vieilles Vignes'" from the vintage 2009 on 01.06.2019 with 95 of 100 points.
yr. 1993 Jasper Morris - Inside Burgundy:
95 of 100 Points.
"Jasper Morris - Inside Burgundy" has rated the wine "Domaine Comte Georges de Vogue Musigny Grand Cru 'Cuvee Vieilles Vignes'" from the vintage 1993 on 01.01.2019 with 95 of 100 points.
